Every year, Nick and Katy choose what films, actors, actresses, directors and songs should win an Academy Award. So for 2004, Rhodes and Krassner give the Oscar to:
WILL WIN: Both Nick and Katy agree that LORD OF THE RINGS RETURN OF THE KING will win BEST PICTURE
SHOULD WIN: We agree - it should be LOST IN TRANSLATION, but sadly, it won't be
WILL WIN: Katy & Nick say PETER JACKSON will win for LORD OF THE RINGS
SHOULD WIN: We think PETER should win too.
WILL WIN: Katy says SEAN PENN will win for MYSTIC RIVER. Nick agrees.
SHOULD WIN: Once again, we agree - BILL MURRAY for LOST IN TRANSLATION but we would both be happy if JOHNNY DEPP got it for PIRATES
WILL WIN: CHARLIZE THERON will win for MONSTER. Agreement again!
SHOULD WIN: Nick says NAOMI WATTS should get it for 21 GRAMS. Katy has no opinion and both of us are still wondering why Scarlett Johnansen wasn't even nominated!!
WILL WIN: We agree that TIM ROBBINS for MYSTIC RIVER will be accepting his Award on Sunday
SHOULD WIN: Nick says BENICIO DEL TORO for 21 GRAMS, Katy says ALEC BALDWIN (Long Island yo!) for THE COOLER
WILL WIN: Both agree that RENEE ZELLEWEGAR will get it for COLD MOUNTAIN, even though we didn't see the movie
SHOULD WIN: Since neither of us have a strong opinion, we are going to say SHOHREH AGHDASHLOO for THE HOUSE OF SAND & FOG
WILL WIN: We're going with ANNIE LENNOX with "Into the West" from LORD OF THE RINGS
SHOULD WIN: Katy & Nick want Mitch and Mickey's KISS AT THE END OF THE RAINBOW from Christopher Guest's fabulous A MIGHTY WIND
WILL WIN: SOFIA COPOLLA!
SHOULD WIN: SOFIA COPOLLA!
WILL WIN: Nick & Katy give it to MYSTIC RIVER
SHOULD WIN: Katy & Nick are in near total agreement this year! AMERICAN SPLENDOR is our "should win"